Proposal: Replacing Heaven and Hell
I believe that Heaven and Hell no longer fit the moralities of RP Fear. In a Role-Play where the main fear comes from the inevitability of death and the idea that the universe is uncaring, having a Heaven/Hell dichotomy is rather unfitting.
Therefore, I have a proposal that I refer to as the Simulation. The name, of course, is pending, but it is related to the fears, and it's an extension one Fear in particular The Archangel, which I feel would be much more fitting to the Role-play's themes.
The Simulation is a form of the Archangel from the main Fear Universe. In the Fear Universe, the Archangel was the Afterlife. The only way to escape being part of the Archangel was to be killed by another Fear directly.
Therefore, I believe that we should take this concept. If a character dies by the hand of anything other than a Fear in a physical form (in which case you simply cease to exist), they become part of Archangel's Simulation. This Simulation is a horrible existence where all men and women, good or evil, go. This means it fits the "uncaring" theme of the universe we are attempting to create, as it would make your character's actions utterly meaningless. They could be a drug-addled cannibal baby-killer, or Jesus himself, and they would go to the same afterlife.
What happens in the Simulation?
You are aware you are dead, but the first sensation you have is of being pushed. You are wet and cold. You have been reborn into one of the countless "Spaces" within the Simulation. There, you live your life. You live every life you could have, always born of the same parents, at the same time. Thus, you live your life, knowing it is a false life, constantly reminded it is a false life. People have no irises, they speak in a monotone. You life your entire life, every possible way your life could have gone. Your actions are not your own. You are trapped, living a false life. Eventually, you die. You think that it's over, you can find peace.
But you feel a pushing. You are cold and wet. The Simulation has you, and it will always have you. You live a thousand billion lives, every single way your life could have gone and every way it could have ended, every variation on your life that could have changed it. So, forever. You remember every past life, and eventually, you start to forget yourself. Your previous life is gone, replaced with one of this countless lives you lived. This happens, ad infinitum until you have lived every possible variation of you life. Then, you cease to be.
This could very easily replace Heaven, Hell, and Purgatory. Reapers would vanish, perhaps, but Demons and Angels could become vagabonds of the world, Shattered Beings. Or, they could combine with each other, or do countless things. They may not have to change at all, actually, still having their war, however, they would simply not reside in Heaven or Hell. Their war would occur in the invisible folds of reality humanity cannot see.
Again, I feel this proposal could easily replace Heaven and Hell, and could fit the theme of the Role-Play well, given the uncaring nature of the new universe and strange, perhaps absent, morality.